We scored 135 private specialty practices on the public Google signals patients actually use. The average audit score was 55.3 out of 100.
75 of 135 (55.6%) did not appear in Google’s Local Pack. That is the first number. Review volume is not the problem. Replies on the newest Google reviews often are.
| Signal | Finding | n |
|---|---|---|
| Average audit score | 55.3 / 100 | 135 |
| Missing from the Local Pack | 55.6% (75) | 135 |
| Zero owner replies on newest Google reviews | 51% (59) | 115 with stored Google reviews |
| Google review volume | 586 reviews at 4.48 stars | 74 with a Google review total |
| Confirmed slow LCP (>2.5s) | 52.6% (71) | 135; 71 of 74 measured |
| No Google Ads | 96.3% (130) | 135 |
How did we score the 135 practices?
We scored completed audits of private US practices. Public Google signals only: Local Pack and Google Business Profile, review volume, owner replies on the newest Google reviews we stored, site speed (LCP), and whether the practice was running Google Ads.
This is not a random national sample, not a client leaderboard, and not a 90-day case study. The 135 are the completed appeario Audits with a score as of September 2026 — dermatology, ophthalmology, and orthopedics make up the largest groups, with neighboring private practices in the same run.
104 of 135 ran as Lite audits. Lite skips ChatGPT and Gemini, so this post does not report AI visibility. Local Pack “present” means the practice appeared in the map module for at least one tracked specialty + city keyword. LCP uses Google’s 2.5-second “good” bar. Review counts and stars come from Google’s listing total. Review replies come from the newest Google reviews our audit stored (lean pull, typically about 30) — not from the full lifetime of a 500-review listing.
How many specialty practices show up in Google’s Local Pack?
75 of 135 (55.6%) did not appear in the Local Pack.
The Local Pack is the map and about three listings at the top of searches like “dermatologist near me” or “knee surgeon in [city].” It is not your website ranking. It is your Google Business Profile, plus categories, reviews, and distance.
If you are not in those three slots, a large share of patients who are ready to book never see you. They call whoever is on the map.
This is the first number to fix if you are going to fix only one. Start with local SEO for doctors and a clean Google Business Profile.
Do doctor reviews matter if nobody replies?
Yes. Volume without replies is only half the job.
The 74 practices with a Google review total averaged 586 reviews at 4.48 stars. That part looks done.
Replies are a different cut. Our audit stores the newest Google reviews (typically about 30), not the full archive. Among 115 practices with those rows, 59 (51%) had zero owner replies on any of them.
The rating is a trophy. The reply thread is the conversation. Patients already wrote the social proof. A lot of listings still say nothing back.
Google treats replies as a sign the listing is alive. Other patients read them before they call. You can thank someone without confirming they are a patient — HIPAA still applies. If this is your gap, see how reviews affect a medical practice and how to manage reviews.
Is a slow practice website costing you patients?
71 of 135 (52.6%) had a confirmed slow Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) — over Google’s 2.5-second “good” bar.
Of the 74 sites our audit could measure, 71 failed (96%). Median LCP among measured sites was 7.9 seconds. 61 audits returned no LCP reading, so they are not counted as slow here.
Patients do not diagnose “LCP.” They leave. Google notices. A slow homepage undercuts every other channel, including ads you are not running yet. If the site is the weak point, why doctors need a website and the pages every practice site needs are the practical checklists.
Are specialty practices running Google Ads?
130 of 135 (96.3%) had no ads. Five were running them.
That is not a moral. For many practices, the Local Pack, replies, and a usable site should come first. It does mean the paid-search auction in these specialties is emptier than the pitch deck implies.
When paid search does make sense — usually when you need patients this month and the organic slots are already taken — start with Google Ads vs. SEO and when healthcare PPC is worth it. Pricing if you want us to run it.
Do ophthalmology, dermatology, and orthopedics score differently?
On the same 100-point scale, the specialties we split out landed here:
- Ophthalmology: 66.8 (n=19)
- Orthopedics: 59.5 (n=15)
- Dermatology: 58.1 (n=41)
- Plastic surgery: 54.8 (n=8)
Different specialties, same gaps. This is a split, not a ranking of who “does marketing.” ENT and other neighboring private specialties are in the 135; we are not going to invent a story for the cuts with a handful of rows. Each specialty page, linked above, shows how its treatment lines are won.
What should a practice do first?
Pick one gap. Finish it. Then the next.
- Out of the Local Pack — claim and clean up Google Business Profile. Categories, hours, photos, services. Then keep it current.
- Newest reviews sitting unanswered — reply to the last 20. Then keep up. Volume and stars are already there for most of the practices we scored.
- The site is slow — fix LCP before you buy traffic.
- You need patients this month and the map is full — then look at paid search.
One gap at a time is slower to announce and faster to finish.
The appeario Audit scores the same public Google picture for your practice. Free. No pitch call.
Run your free appeario Audit →
FAQs
What did the 135-practice Google visibility audit find?
The average audit score was 55.3 out of 100. 75 of 135 practices (55.6%) did not appear in Google's Local Pack. Review volume is high; replies on the newest Google reviews often are not. This cut does not report ChatGPT or Gemini visibility.
How many specialty practices are missing from the Google Local Pack?
75 of 135 (55.6%) did not appear in the Local Pack. That map-and-three-listings block is driven mainly by Google Business Profile, not by another website rewrite.
Do specialty practices reply to their Google reviews?
Often no. Among 115 practices with Google reviews our audit stored, 59 (51%) had zero owner replies on those newest reviews. The 74 practices with a Google review total still averaged 586 reviews at 4.48 stars.
How was the audit score calculated?
Each practice got a 0–100 score from public Google signals — Local Pack and organic visibility, review volume and recent replies, site speed, directory presence, and whether ads were running. Most of these audits were Lite, so ChatGPT and Gemini were not pulled.
What should a specialty practice fix first?
If you are missing from the Local Pack, claim and clean Google Business Profile first. Then reply to the newest Google reviews. Then fix LCP if the site is slow. Paid search last, if the map is already full and you need patients this month.